Defining polyamory | What is polyamory? | Forum

Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering


Lost Your Password?

Search Forums:


 






Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

UserPost

7:36 am
April 30, 2010


jbash

Admin

We've been using Wikipedia's definition of the word "polyamory":

"Polyamory is the practice, desire, or acceptance of having more than one intimate relationship at a time with the knowledge and consent of everyone involved"

We chose this definition because it had been discussed by many interested people, and we felt we had no chance of coming up with a more legitimate definition in the time available to us. However, there are some problems.

The second biggest problem is that the Wikipedia definition makes it hard for us to talk about the community we represent. It appears to include any patriarchal polygyny that has valid consent. However, the people who identify with the word "polyamory", tend to have a value system vastly different from those who practice patriarchal polygyny.

The biggest problem is that we're not sure that the Wikipedia definition is really what our constituents mean when they talk about polyamory. When asked, polyamorous people tend to talk about value systems and social structures… and those aren't part of the Wikipedia definition. We seem to hear a lot about "freedom", "equality", and "choice" from polyamorists.

It's also true that the technical definition of "polygamy" includes many polyamorous relationships… yet the people who identify with the word "polygamy" tend to strongly reject the values of those who identify with the word "polyamory". They seem to see us as too willing to discard tradition, too unwilling to play prescribed social roles, too open to uncommitted relationships, and too sexually permissive.

Neither group really wants to be associated with the other, yet the words available to us, at least under the definitions we've been using, tend to blur the distinctions.

We've considered several possiblities:

  1. We could qualify the words. We already say "patriarchal polygyny". We could also say "egalitarian polyamory". But that would make our text even wordier and more confusing.

  2. We could make a distinction between "polyamorists" (those who identify with a value system and a social structure) and "polyamory" (a practice). But that's a very subtle distinction to ask readers to make.

  3. We could try to use a definition of "polyamory" closer to what polyamorists seem to use. That would probably mean defining it more in terms of social structure and mores, and less in terms of the simple practice of multiple relationships.

So, what do you think? What does "polyamory" mean to you?

7:51 pm
May 11, 2010


jbash

Admin

Our fundamental position statement hasn't generated a lot of discussion, probably because it's a pretty simple question.The forum on the definition of polyamory is now open for business…

6:15 pm
May 29, 2010


charlier

New Member

jbash said:

Our fundamental position statement hasn't generated a lot of discussion, probably because it's a pretty simple question.The forum on the definition of polyamory is now open for business…


There is no reason we can't alter the wikipedia definitions of polyamory and/or polygamy and comment why so that people are less likely to change it back.  I have been tempted to do this since I watch the polyamory entry and see people changing it all the time but don't feel authoritative enough to actually make the change alone, but I would be pleased to make any changes we agree on in this forum and comment that these are changes that have been arrived on by consensus here, which will give them extra weight.

8:37 pm
June 6, 2010


CChanteuse

Guest

Thank you for your contribution here, CharlieR and for starting off the conversation jbash.

I prefer option 3.   Using a clarification definition that tries to address the values and mores of the polyamory community in addition to the concept of simply having multiple relationships. 

 

4:49 pm
July 7, 2010


Meltemi

New Member

I think the problem with changing the definition to what you prefer is that it is less all-encompassing and more specific.  Polyamory means different things to everyone, and by further defining it, some people may be cut out of the mix

7:49 am
July 10, 2010


Kimmie

Member

If we use the words 'freedoms', 'choice', etc. that polyamory people have used themselves, it (hopefully) wouldn't cut anyone out. I agree that a little bit of separation needs to be applied here though. Usually, if I speak to someone about being poly, they assume swinger, or polygamy. (not to open up the swinger debate or anything, that's just 1 of the 2 usual responses)

 

Maybe if it were to be changed with the update version of what polyamory means with a side 'not to be confused with polygamy – " and a short, quick definition of that?

No Tags
Reply to Post


Reply to Topic:
Defining polyamory

Guest Name (Required):

Post New Reply

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
12 + 1